Adventures in Learning

Making the case for e-books and digital handouts

So what’s so great about e-textbooks and digital documents anyway?

The move is on towards « 0-paper » based learning.  Schools are rolling out e-readers, using online textbooks, making use of the numerous OERs (Open Educational Resources) that sites like OpenStax have to offer. But what is the learning value of digital materials exactly?

The psuedo argument

Some would argue that they offer a great way to save paper and that e-reading offers the reader the chance to have fewer books to manage – everything at your finger tips.  I believe these are false or pseudo arguments FOR e-textbooks.  They are primarily arguments AGAINST having physical books or articles. Want to decrease the weight of a backpack, don’t use books. Want to save on paper – don’t give out photocopies.

The danger with these pseudo arguments is that they don’t propose the value added reasons FOR learners to adopt an e-textbook or digital assignment. As a result, the potential user is quick to note the disadvantages of e-books.

The case FOR e-reading

Some of the benefits of e-reading can be found in recent history.


When I was a student, library books were checked out using a library card.  A card in the book was stamped and signed with my name indicating when it was to be returned. Looking through books on the library shelf, one could easily see how popular a book was, who was reading it, etc.

So why is this important?

To start, the borrower could easily measure

  1. the popularity of a book and it’s potential usefulness
  2. the kind of people that were reading the book (like me? from my class? the teacher? students that were getting good grades?)
  3. the recency of the book’s use
  4. etc.

Digital resources offer schools and libraries the same advantage. With some simple management of user data, the school library should be able to help a learner find a book based on popularity of readers « like » the learner.  But much more than that, the library can offer detailed non-confidential meta-data such as:

  1. Borrowing of the book by student enrollment (which books are most often borrowed by students in Econ 101?)
  2. Borrowing of the book by student characteristics (age, gender, etc.)
  3. Complementary and substitute books (people who borrowed the book also borrowed ABC;  this book is just like XYZ)

But e-reading can go even further.  The same analysis can eventually be done chapter by chapter of a book. How many times a certain chapter or page was read. etc.

Shared Annotations

When I bought textbooks, I often bought them used. This not only provided a way to save money – it also provided me with key information to increase my learning performance. I spent considerable time reviewing the books to see which one was highlighted in a selective and clear manner.

While the learner may not be « like me », it was likely that we shared some of the same learning needs as the book was most likely used in the previous semester in the same course.

So now, some of the work was done for me.  In addition, the previous owner would leave comments in the margins. A nice added bonus.

So what about digital texts?

If you’re working with a pdf file, the KAMI reader allows for co-annotation and shared annotation of the article.  A really nice feature.  Other pdf readers and even Google Docs offer similar features. There are also mobile apps that do the same. Students can co-annotate and highlight texts. The amazon Kindle also offers reader the chance to see Popular Highlights and Public Notes.

MIT has developed an open application called Annotation Studio  that allows for collaborative annotation. Student feedback of the MIT tool shows the value of co-annotation.

« So I really enjoyed using your website, it was easy to navigate and accomplished what it was supposed to do. I appreciate that we can add links and videos for future reference. Very cool to see the rest of the class annotations as well. Would be interesting to create mini-groups for projects, etc. Strengths: clean layout, simple, easy to use. Would also like different colors of highlighters. Thanks. »

« It was fun and easy to use. I liked how we could see the class annotations as well. »

« It was very easy to use and was helpful to be able to annotate an online source. Also very helpful to be able to see other people’s annotations and ideas to further progress my own thoughts and understanding of the reading. »

Making e-reading a reality

So how can we move e-reading forward? Here are some tips.

  1. E-reading offers some unique advantages to hard copy books and articles. Assignments should be made that have students explore these advantages (ex. co-annotation). Make sure students and professors have learned HOW to read and learn with digital handouts and books. It’s much different.
  2. Make sure the devices used are appropriate.  Using devices with digital ink make the digital reading experience much more easy on the eyes. The TEA reader (French) is a good example as is the Kindle Paperwhite.
  3. Avoid the « paper saving » argument. This is a pseudo argument and is not promoting e-reading. It is an institutional/social benefit, of course, but will not engage the learner in using e-reading.
  4. Start managing meta-data of e-books and online pdf files.  Use metadata to help learners find chapters, and books that meet their needs.  So much meta-data exists – the question is using it correctly and in an ethical manner.





Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *

Ce site utilise Akismet pour réduire les indésirables. En savoir plus sur comment les données de vos commentaires sont utilisées.